2015 ∙ T ∙ 1h 59min
Una storia d’amore fittizia liberamente ispirata alle vite delle artiste danesi Lili Elbe e Gerda Wegener. L’unione e il lavoro di Lili e Gerda evolvono mentre navigano attraverso le complessità del percorso rivoluzionario di Lili come pioniera transgender.
Regia Tom Hooper
Copenhagen, Denmark, 1926. Einar Wegener (played by Eddie Redmayne) and his wife Gerda (Alicia Vikander) are a happily married couple. Both are artists, Einar preferring landscapes and she portraits. One day Einar poses for a portrait of Gerda’s while wearing a dress. This is initially done as a lark, as is the later attendance at a party dressed as a woman. However, Einar soon discovers that she is in fact a woman and over time prefers being Lili. At first she and Gerda try to have her situation “cured” but this leads nowhere (other than to many doctors trying to have Lili locked up as a pervert and/or lunatic). Her voyage of self-discovery will ultimately lead to her undergoing the first ever sex-change operation.
Lili consulted two physicians, both of whom diagnosed her as homosexual, a third physician diagnosed her as intersexed and claimed she had rudimentary female sex organs. In fact, when the sex reassignment surgery commenced, the surgeons found shrunken female ovaries. Hormonal assays taken just before her first surgery indicated more female than male hormones present. It is likely that she had XXY sex chromosome karyotype (Klinefelter’s Syndrome) a condition not medically recognized until 1942. The fact that Lili was Intersex is not mentioned in the film.
Vikander shines but overall it didn’t connect with me as expected
The new cinema year has got off to a robust start with the new movie from Tom Hooper (“The King’s Speech”, “Les Misérables”).
We have seen many depictions of physical torture on the screen over the years, from the interminable teen-slasher pics, through ‘that chair scene’ in “Casino Royale” to the stylized presentations of Quentin Tarantino and Martin Scorsese in films like “Reservoir Dogs” and “Casino”. “The Danish Girl” is also in its way a film about torture, but more akin to the mental torture seen in films like “Buried” or “Flightpath”. What must it be like to be trapped with a sexual orientation that you feel is not your own? To possess physical body parts you don’t believe you should have? And all in a time (the 1920’s) when an exposed ankle was considered slightly daring.
Based on a true story, Oscar-winner Eddie Redmayne (“The Theory of Everything”) and Alicia Vikander (“Ex Machina”) play a bohemian married couple Einar and Gerda Wegener, apparently happily married and trying for a child in 1920’s Copenhagen. Einar is a renowned landscape artist with his wife a struggling portrait artist living in his shadow. After taking part in a cross-dressing modelling session, strong feelings are awakened in Einar. As a bit of a ‘game’ Gerda encourages him to explore the character of his alter-ego “Lili” further: a big mistake, as Einar is swept into a spiral of confusion and self-doubt.
Eddie Redmayne is surely up for another Oscar-nomination for his brave performance as Einar/Lili, using his expressive eyes to great effect and delivering a truly heart-rending performance. With all this said however, I never quite believed I was watching the character of Lili but more Redmayne acting the character. Perhaps this is unfair, as Einar/Lili is such a bizarrely multi-dimensional person no one could perhaps have played him/her to my satisfaction. But I suspect (particularly as Redmayne won last year) this won’t bring Redmayne the Oscar double.
Far more impressive for me was the delicious and delightful Alicia Vikander, once more turning in a fantastic performance as the increasingly desperate (both psychologically and sexually) Gerda. With Rooney Mara, Vikander must be one of the brightest actress talents in today’s cinema.
Also turning in a strong performance, in what is a very limited cast list, is Matthias Schoenaerts (“Far from the Madding Crowd”) as a Parisian art dealer with a link to Einar’s past. The omni-present (sorry, that should read “hard-working”) Ben Whishaw turns up again as a party guest with an unhealthy interest in Lili and Sebastian Koch (most recently seen in series 5 of “Homeland”) plays Dr Warnekros who is a pioneer in the new and risky business of sexual reassignment surgery.
Another star of the film is the luscious Danish capital, filmed in vibrant colours, as if from the artists’ palettes, by Danny Cohen, a Hooper favourite. Also a big surprise to me was the gloriously photographed Danish countryside, seen at the end of the film, with mountains and seascapes I never knew existed.
Another Hooper alumni, Alexandre Desplat, supplies the soupy but very fitting score.
While the film features a compelling story and much impressive acting, I never personally felt as connected to the story as I was to “The King’s Speech”. This isn’t helped by a rather stagy script by Lucinda Coxon that feels lightweight at times. Perhaps its because we are in Oscar- season but, to me, it all felt a tad pretentious and (no pun intended) could have done with a few snips in places to reduce the running time by 15 minutes or so. That being said, and as an alternative view, I should point out that my wife was in tears for a good proportion of the film and disagrees vehemently with my views. I say “my wife”, but since watching the film she’s started wearing braces and smoking cigars – so I’m rather confused as to WHAT exactly is going on. 🙂
Fotografia Danny Cohen
Montaggio Melanie Oliver
Luoghi delle riprese Copenhagen, Denmark
Distribuzione Focus Feature (United States) ∙ Universal Pictures (International)
Aziende produttrici Working Title Film ∙ Pretty Pictures ∙ ReVision Pictures ∙ Senator Global Productions
Runtime 1 hr 59 min (119 min)
Camera Red Epic Dragon, Zeiss Master Prime Lenses
Cinematographic Process Digital Intermediate (2K) (master format)
Printed Film Format D-Cinema
Red Epic Dragon, Zeiss Master Prime Lenses
Sito ufficiale Working Title Films
What an excellent film it is, never in my life I have seen such an engaging movie.
I remember the first time I saw this movie, and I’m still amazed!